Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings

Menupickcom

Tommy's Tavern + Tap menu

18 dishes across 5 sections $20 to $30 Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Tommy's Tavern + Tap photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Sandwiches 12 dishes

  • Grilled Ahi Tuna Wrap $20.00

    Rare ahi tuna, sliced avocado, soy ginger marinade, lettuce, red onions & wasabi mayo in a wrap, served with fries

  • Brisket Sandwch $22.00

    Sliced smoked prime Texas brisket topped with frizzled onions, house slaw and carolina bbq sauce on a toasted brioche bun, served with fries

  • Old School Chicken Salad Sandwich $18.00

    Roasted chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, hellman’s mayo, crispy bacon, craisins, celery & onions on toasted sourdough bread, served with fries

  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich $19.00

    Creamy pesto, mozzarella & roasted red pepper on toasted ciabatta bread, served with fries

  • Crispy Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich $19.00

    Hand battered chicken tenders, chipotle mayo, topped with melted pepper jack, sliced tomato & apple slaw on toasted ciabatta bread, served with fries

  • *NEW* Steak Sandwich $24.00

    Sliced flat iron steak topped with neuske's pepper bacon, cooper black pepper cheese, caramelized onions, red onions, arugula & garlic horseradish aioli on toasted ciabatta bread, served with fries

  • The Cubano $18.00

    Sliced pork loin, ham, Swiss, pickles & cherry pepper mustard on grilled ciabatta bread, served with chips

  • Classic Bacon Grilled Cheese $18.00

    Bacon, melted cheddar & tomato on toasted sourdough bread with tomato basil soup

  • Tavern Dip $24.00

    Sliced prime rib, caramelized onions, mozzarella & horseradish cream on garlic ciabatta bread with fries

  • Blackened Mahi Sandwich $18.00

    Lettuce, tomato & jalapeño ranch on a toasted brioche bun, served with fries

  • Pulled Pork Sandwich $17.00

    Topped with coal fired roasted onions & coleslaw on a toasted brioche bun with kettle chips

  • Blackened Shrimp Wrap $19.00

    Lettuce, tomato, sliced avocado & chipotle mayo in a wrap, served with fries

White Specialty Pies 9 dishes

  • Milano $21.00

    Grilled artichokes, fresh garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • Americana Buffalo Pie $20.00

    Breaded chicken, celery, mozzarella, hot sauce & ranch dressing

  • The Cowboy $21.00

    BBQ pulled pork, coal fired roasted onions, mozzarella & smoked gouda

  • The Donatello $22.00

    Imported prosciutto di parma, mozzarella, arugula, fig jam & balsamic glaze

  • Gaston’s Burrata Primavera $22.00

    Cherry tomatoes, shaved red onions, fresh burrata, garlic sauce, basil & balsamic drizzle

  • The BBQ Pie $21.00

    BBQ grilled chicken, mozzarella, smoked gouda, shaved red onions & fresh cilantro

  • Mr. B's Favorite $20.00

    Cherry tomatoes, fresh garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • Logan's Bianco $20.00

    Arugula, mozzarella, shaved grana padana, fresh squeezed lemon juice & extra virgin olive oil

  • Quattro Formaggi $21.00

    Smoked gouda, sliced fresh mozzarella, shredded mozzarella, and grana padana

Poke Bowls 5 dishes

  • Happy Vegetarian $16.00

    Avocado, cucumber, asparagus, carrot tossed in a wasabi infused ponzu sauce, served with ginger

  • Spiced Up Shrimp Bowl $19.00

    Dressed with spicy mayo, avocado, ginger, cucumber, tossed in a wasabi infused ponzu sauce & topped with masago & cilantro

  • Spicy Yellowtail Bowl $23.00

    Yellowtail, fresh jalapeño, avocado, ginger, cucumber & cilantro tossed in a wasabi infused ponzu sauce & topped with masago

  • Super Salmon Bowl $20.00

    Salmon, avocado, cucumber, tossed in a wasabi infused ponzu sauce & topped with crab surimi salad, with a touch of spicy mayo & eel sauce

  • Classic Tuna Poke Bowl $20.00

    Tuna, avocado, ginger, cucumber, cilantro tossed in a wasabi infused ponzu sauce & topped with masago

Desserts 6 dishes

  • Toffee Cake $12.00

    Served with vanilla ice cream and fresh whipped cream

  • Brookie $12.00

  • Aunt Jacqui's Bread Pudding $10.00

    A housemade rum bread pudding, stuffed with currants, served with vanilla ice cream and coconut rum sauce

  • GS Choc Cake $12.00

    Flourless chocolate cake served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, fresh whipped cream and chocolate syrup

  • Lava Cake $12.00

    Decadent classic warm cake with vanilla ice cream and fresh whipped cream

  • GS Key Lime Pie $10.00

    (Gluten Sensitive) served with whip cream

Calzones + Strombolis 2 dishes

  • Calzone Di Apulia $17.00

    Lightly brushed with extra virgin olive oil, filled with ricotta & mozzarella

  • Taormina Stromboli $15.00

    Lightly brushed with extra virgin olive oil, house-made dough stuffed with mozzarella

Red Speciality Pies 11 dishes

  • The Bruno $19.00

    Breaded chicken, hot cherry peppers, mozzarella, san marzano tomatoes, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • Hot Honey Roni $20.00

    Sesame seeded crust, cup and char peperoni, sliced mozzarella, housemade marinara & hot honey

  • Cauliflower Pizza $13.00

    8" cauliflower crust with san marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, grated romano, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • Gluten Free Pizza $16.00

    12" gluten free crust with san marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, grated romano, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • Bella Andrea $20.00

    Sweet Italian sausage, Coal fired Onions, mozzarella, gorgonzola, san marzano tomatoes, basil and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Il Isabella Pizza $20.00

    Breaded eggplant, mozzarella, ricotta cheese, san marzano tomatoes, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • Yvette's Veggie $22.00

    Grilled eggplant, zucchini, fresh garlic, roasted red peppers, mozzarella, san marzano tomatoes, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • Margherita $19.00

    Sliced mozzarella, san marzano tomatoes, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • San Danielle $22.00

    Imported prosciutto di parma, arugula, fresh mozzarella, grana padana, san marzano tomatoes & extra virgin olive oil

  • Pizza Alla Russa $19.00

    Grilled chicken, mozzarella, pecorino, vodka sauce & basil

  • Della Valle $20.00

    Sausage, cup and char pepperoni, meatballs, mozzarella, san marzano tomatoes, basil & extra virgin olive oil

Large Plates 8 dishes

  • Penne Vodka With Chicken $24.00

    House made vodka sauce with spiced grilled chicken

  • Bulgogi Tacos $20.00

    Three flour tacos with sliced Korean bbq short rib, kimchi, pickled onions, sriracha crema and cilantro, served with kimchi fried rice

  • Fish N Chips $22.00

    Beer battered cod with housemade tartar sauce, served with french fries

  • Chicken Parm $26.00

    Two hand breaded chicken cutlets topped with house made marinara sauce & fresh mozzarella served with penne pasta

  • NY Strip Steak $40.00

    14 oz choice center cut with housemade steak sauce, served with truffle fries

  • Ribeye $42.00

    14 oz choice boneless ribeye grilled with our signature rub, with housemade steak sauce, served with crispy smashed potatoes

  • Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese $20.00

    Our signature cheddar cheese sauce, with bbq pulled pork and seasoned bread crumbs, served with toasted cornbread

  • Vodka Chicken Parm $28.00

    Two hand breaded chicken cutlets topped with house made vodka sauce & fresh mozzarella served with penne pasta

Tradition Roll 9 dishes

  • Califorina Roll $10.00

    Crab stick, avocado & cucumber

  • Philly Roll $12.00

    Smoked salmon, cream cheese, cucumber & avocado

  • Sushicado Roll $13.00

    Choice of one: tuna, shrimp, yellowtail or salmon with avocado

  • Spicy Salmon Roll $12.00

    Spicy salmon with cucumber, topped with crunchy onions & spicy mayo

  • Veggie Roll $9.00

    Choose one or all of the following: asparagus, carrot, cucumber, or avocado

  • Spicy Shrimp Roll $12.00

    Spicy shrimp with cucumber, topped with crunchy onions & spicy mayo

  • Spicy Crab Roll $12.00

    Spicy crab with cucumber, topped with crunchy onions & spicy mayo

  • Tempura Shrimp Roll $13.00

    Tempura shrimp, carrot & avocado with eel sauce 13 Spicy Lobster Roll lobster surimi salad with spicy mayo

  • Spicy Tuna Roll $12.00

    Spicy tuna with cucumber, topped with crunchy onions & spicy mayo

Kids 8 dishes

  • Kids Penne W/Butter $8.00

    Penne pasta with melted butter

  • Kids Penne Meatball $10.00

    Penne pasta with housemade marinara and a meatball

  • Kids Mac N Cheese $10.00

  • Kid Pizza $9.00

    10" personal classic with sauce on the bottom and shredded mozzarella on top

  • Kids Cheese Burger $10.00

    Two beef sliders topped with cheese, served with fries

  • Kids Penne Marinara $8.00

    Penne pasta with housemade marinara

  • Kid Chicken Tender $9.00

    Three chicken tenders served with fries

  • Kids Grilled Cheese $9.00

Signature Roll 10 dishes

  • Latitudes Roll $19.00

    Salmon, avocado, topped with spicy tuna, crunchy onions, eel sauce & spicy mayo

  • The Tavern Roll $21.00

    Tuna, salmon, topped with seared pepper tuna, lobster surimi salad, spicy mayo & eel sauce

  • Lobster Dragon $19.00

    Shrimp tempura, carrot, avocado, topped with lobster surimi salad & spicy mayo

  • Shrimp Dragon $18.00

    Spicy shrimp, cucumber, topped with nigiri shrimp, spicy mayo & eel sauce

  • Super Yellowtail Roll $21.00

    Yellowtail, avocado, cucumber, topped with yellowtail, sliced jalapeño, masago, spicy mayo & eel sauce

  • Super Philly $18.00

    Smoked salmon, cream cheese, cucumber, avocado, topped with smoked salmon, avocado & spicy mayo

  • Tempura Dragon $18.00

    Tempura shrimp, avocado, carrot, topped with spicy tuna, spicy mayo & eel sauce

  • Crabby Gabby Roll $18.00

    Crab stick, cucumber, avocado, topped with spicy crab surimi salad & spicy mayo

  • Tommys Roll $20.00

    Yellowtail, avocado, cucumber, topped with jalapeño, salmon, pepper tuna & cilantro

  • Christmas Roll $19.00

    Spicy tuna, cucumber, topped with tuna, yellowtail, avocado, spicy mayo & eel sauce

Flatbreads 7 dishes

  • Christina's Prosciutto Padana $18.00

    Imported prosciutto di parma, coal fired onions, seasoned cream, grana padana & mozzarella

  • Spinach And Artichoke $17.00

    Creamy spinach, artichokes, fresh garlic, shredded mozzarella & diced tomatoes

  • Eggplant Caprese $17.00

    Breaded eggplant, pesto sauce, mozzarella & blistered cherry tomatoes, drizzled with a balsamic reduction

  • Spicy Mikey $18.00

    Meatballs, fresh garlic, mozzarella, san marzano tomato sauce, & ricotta, drizzled with hot honey

  • Timoteo's Trifecta $16.00

    Pesto, vodka sauce, san marzano tomato sauce & mozzarella

  • Cheesy Garlic Flatbread $15.00

    Fresh garlic, mozzarella, herbs & spices

  • Mrs. B's Shrimp Scampi $18.00

    Jumbo shrimp, white wine butter sauce, mozzarella & seasoned bread crumbs with fresh lemon

Small Plates 18 dishes

  • Tap House Meatballs $17.00

    All beef mix served with ricotta, pecorino & housemade marinara

  • Spinach & Artichoke Dip $16.00

    Served with tortilla chips

  • Firecracker 50/50 $20.00

    Lightly fried calamari and shrimp in a cajun tempura batter, tossed in our signature sweet & spicy sauce, topped with scallions and sesame seeds

  • Fried Calamari $19.00

    With housemade marinara & garlic aioli

  • Coal Fired Jumbo Pretzel $14.00

    Jumbo bavarian pretzel with housemade Brooklyn lager cheese sauce & spicy mustard sauce

  • L.A. Sliders $18.00

    Mustard grilled burgers cooked to medium, melted cheddar, lettuce, pickles & burger sauce on mini brioche buns with kettle chips

  • Hot Honey Chicken Bites $16.00

    Buttermilk fried chicken thighs and crispy wontons tossed in hot honey with scallions & sesame seeds

  • Mediterranean Platter $18.00

    Garlic and roasted red pepper hummus, tabbouleh salad, feta, naan bread, carrots, celery, olives, pickled red onions & cucumber

  • Loaded Nachos $16.00

    Your choice of chili, bbq pulled pork or grilled chicken, topped with cheddar jack, jalapeño, black olives, pico de gallo & sour cream

  • 10 Piece Coal Oven Wings $18.00

    Tommy's original coal oven roasted wings topped with coal fired roasted onions & an italian long hot pepper

  • General Tso's Cauliflower $14.00

    Lightly battered and fried cauliflower and peppadew peppers, in general tso's sauce with scallions

  • Tavern Taquitos $15.00

    Pulled chicken breast, cheddar jack, roasted corn salsa & fresh salsa rolled into a flour tortilla, fried and topped with chipotle mayo & a side of chili sauce

  • Housemade Rosemary Focaccia $6.00

    Coal fired, housemade, rosemary foccacia bread served with oil & marinara on the side

  • Holy Guacamole! $14.00

    Avocado, pico de gallo & chopped jalapeño, served with tortilla chips

  • Breaded Wisconsin Cheese Curds $13.00

    With housemade marinara

  • Sticky Asian Ribs $17.00

    Crispy baby back ribs in a spicy, sweet sauce topped with fried ginger, scallions & sesame seeds

  • Kung Pao Chicken Dumpling $14.00

    Eight pan-fried dumplings with scallions, crispy onions & chile oil, with ponzu sauce

  • Crispy Brussel Sprouts $13.00

    Whole grain honey mustard sauce, smoked bacon & roasted shallots

Seasonal Specials 4 dishes

  • Reuben Eggrolls $16.00

    Sliced corned beef, sauerkraut and swiss cheese, stuffed in a crispy eggroll wrapper, served with Russian dressing

  • Blueberry-Pear Brie Flatbread $18.00

    Mozzarella + brie cheeses, sliced pear and fresh blueberries topped with balsamic glaze and candied pecans

  • Mortadella Piadina $18.00

    Rustic Italian flatbread sandwich with mortadella, mozzarella and provolone cheeses, baby arugula and mustard aioli, served with fries

  • Pork Scarpariello $36.00

    Char-grilled cowboy pork chop with sweet Italian sausage, caramelized onions, cherry peppers, and roasted red peppers, finished with a balsamic glaze and parsley. Served over crispy smashed potatoes.

Soup & Salad 17 dishes

  • Sliced Beet Salad $17.00

    Mixed greens, goat cheese, red and yellow beets & pecans with white balsamic dressing

  • Tomato Basil Soup $8.00

  • Shrimp Cobb Salad $24.00

    Large shrimp, diced bacon, hard boiled eggs, romaine, gorgonzola, red onions, tomatoes & avocado with ranch dressing

  • Arugula Salad $16.00

    Baby arugula, cherry tomatoes, shaved grana padana & grilled artichokes with lemon vinaigrette

  • Crock Of Chili $12.00

    Cheddar jack + red onion

  • Buffalo Chicken Salad $18.00

    Crispy chicken, bacon, gorgonzola, romaine, cherry tomatoes & celery with ranch dressing

  • Apple Salad $15.00

    Romaine, gorgonzola, granny smith apples, candied pecans & dried cranberries with apple cider vinaigrette

  • Classic Caesar Salad $15.00

    Romaine, croutons & shaved grana padana with our housemade caesar dressing

  • Side Arugula $9.00

    Baby arugula, cherry tomatoes, shaved grana padana & grilled artichokes with lemon vinaigrette

  • Side House Salad $7.00

    Romaine, red onions, cherry tomatoes, chickpeas, celery & kalamata olives with our house dressing

  • Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna Salad $26.00

    Seared rare ahi tuna, baby kale, toasted almonds, carrots, tangerines & shredded jicama with blood orange vinaigrette

  • Tommy's House Salad $13.00

    Romaine, red onions, cherry tomatoes, chickpeas, celery & kalamata olives with our house dressing

  • Side Apple $8.00

    Romaine, gorgonzola, granny smith apples, candied pecans & dried cranberries with apple cider vinaigrette

  • Side Caesar Salad $8.00

    Romaine, croutons & shaved parmigiano reggiano with our homemade caesar dressing

  • Grilled Salmon Salad $26.00

    Grilled blackened salmon, hard boiled eggs, fresh greens, red onions, roasted tomatoes & slivered almonds with blood orange vinaigrette

  • Steak Salad $27.00

    8oz sliced steak grilled to medium, mixed greens, gorgonzola, oven roasted tomatoes & pickled onions, topped with truffle crisps and our house dressing

  • Lobster Bisque $14.00

Tommy's Classic Pies 3 dishes

  • 10" Personal Classic Pizza $11.00

    10" Personal Classic Pizza with san marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, grated romano, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • 14" Medium Classic Pizza $15.00

    14" Medium Classic Pizza with san marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, grated romano, basil & extra virgin olive oil

  • 16" Large Classic Pizza $19.00

    16" Large Classic Pizza with san marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, grated romano, basil & extra virgin olive oil

Tavern Bites 10 dishes

  • Housemade Rosemary Focaccia $6.00

    Coal fired, housemade, rosemary foccacia bread served with oil & marinara on the side

  • Crunchy Sweet Potato Tots $7.00

    Served with cinnamon marshmallow sauce

  • Coleslaw $5.00

  • Truffle Fries $10.00

  • Fries $6.00

  • Fried Pickles $8.00

    Served with jalapeno ranch

  • Chicken Fingers & Fries $13.00

    Four chicken tenders, served with fries

  • Kettle Chips $6.00

  • Onion Rings $7.00

  • Sweet Potato Fries $7.00

    Served with cinnamon marshmallow sauce

Sushi Starters 9 dishes

  • Sushi Sandwich $17.00

    Spicy tuna, avocado and warm sushi rice wrapped in soy paper with spicy mayo, eel sauce & crunchy onions

  • Shrimp Tempura App $16.00

    With sweet chili dipping sauce 8 pcs.

  • Tuna Tartare $17.00

    Our finest tuna tossed with avocado & ponzu sauce, served on a bed of seaweed salad, topped with sesame seeds

  • Side Rice $3.00

  • Camille's Edamame $10.00

    Steamed with a squeeze of lime & a pinch of sea salt, served with a side of ponzu sauce

  • Avocado Boat $14.00

    Avocado halves, topped with crab surimi salad, spicy mayo

  • Seaweed Salad $8.00

  • Sushi Pizza $19.00

    Crispy scallion pancake topped with tuna sashimi, jalapeño, spicy mayo, eel sauce, cilantro & crunchy onions

  • Sushi Nachos $20.00

    Crispy wonton chips, diced spicy yuzu saku tuna, avocado, pickled jalapeño, spicy mayo, eel sauce, ginger, cilantro & masago

Burgers 7 dishes

  • Bacon Swiss Burger $20.00

    Freshly ground 10oz burger, topped with Neuske's pepper bacon, melted Swiss, coal fired roasted onions & bacon aioli on a toasted english muffin, served with fries

  • Hickory-Bbq Burger $20.00

    Freshly ground 10oz burger, bacon, topped with melted cheddar, red onion & hickory barbecue sauce on a toasted brioche bun with fries

  • Veggie Crunch Burger $16.00

    Double veggie patties topped with melted cheddar, sliced avocado, mayonnaise, pickles, tomato, red onions and lettuce on a toasted brioche bun, served with fries

  • Impossible Burger $19.00

    Topped with melted pepper jack, red onions, pickles, lettuce, tomato & a mustard aioli sauce on a toasted brioche bun, served with a house salad

  • Cali Burger $20.00

    Freshly ground 10oz burger, topped with melted pepper jack, avocado, red onions & chipotle mayo on a toasted brioche bun, served with fries

  • Triple T's Cheeseburger $19.00

    Freshly ground 10oz burger, topped with melted cheddar, tomato, red onions & lettuce on a toasted brioche bun, served with fries

  • Southwest Turkey Burger $19.00

    Freshly ground turkey, topped with swiss cheese, avocado, chipotle ranch, tomato, red onion & lettuce on a toasted brioche bun, served with fries

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Other menus in Newark

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Newark listings
Call Menu Directions